

David Adler recently published a provocative report, The Speaker Industrial Complex, about what is happening to the traditional conference speaker model.
One passage in his “Preview to the White Paper” article stopped me cold.
Adler argues that conference organizers often “waste the slot by defaulting to a panel with a moderator and twenty minutes of Q&A,” even though many organizers will privately admit that it is one of the weakest structures on their agenda.
Ouch.
As someone who has spent a good part of my career helping meeting professionals, moderators, and panelists create better panel discussions, I wanted to object….but I couldn’t. Because he’s right.
That kind of panel IS often one of the weakest sessions at a conference.
But I don’t think the problem is the panel. The problem is the “default” structure of a panel.
Adler’s larger proposition is even more interesting than his critique of panels. He suggests that when an event invests in what happens onstage, it is really buying some combination of four different currencies:
Yet these currencies don’t necessarily play nicely together. Spectacle and marketing tend to thrive at scale. Learning and networking tend to benefit from smaller groups and facilitation. Adler argues that the organizer’s job is not to pick one, but to manage the portfolio intentionally.
I agree…although I would make one small change. I’d replace “networking” with “connection”.
IMHO, “networking” can feel transactional, while “connection” is broader. A panelist’s story can resonate with me.
One idea might spark a connection to my own experience.
The person sitting beside me may offer a perspective I hadn’t considered.
I might even discover that 200 other people in the room are wrestling with exactly the same challenge I am!
So Adler’s framework got me wondering, can a panel discussion deliver spectacle, marketing, learning AND connection?
Yes, it can; but not by default and certainly not by putting four experts on stools, handing someone a microphone, and reserving twenty minutes at the end for Q&A.
That isn’t panel design; that’s scheduling.
A powerful panel requires someone to intentionally design and facilitate the experience. And that starts with rethinking the role of the moderator.
For years, I have defined a panel discussion as a live or virtual discussion among selected “D.E.E.P.” panelists who share differing perspectives in front of an audience, facilitated by a skilled moderator.
Notice that last part of the sentence: “facilitated by a skilled moderator”.
A moderator’s job isn’t simply to welcome everyone, introduce the panelists, ask the questions on a prepared list, watch the clock, and announce, “We have time for one last question.”
The moderator is there to facilitate a conversation worth having. When the moderator approaches the job as a facilitator, a panel has the potential to deliver all four currencies:
This is where Adler’s report becomes particularly interesting: He observes that the professional speaking industry has an established infrastructure for selling speakers, while facilitation does not have the same fee structure, representation, or marketplace.
I see that firsthand. I have several speaker bureaus that represent me as a speaker, yet not one represents me as a facilitator. It isn’t because facilitation has less value. It is partly because the industry knows how to package and sell a speaker: A speaker has a topic, a description, a demo reel, a fee, and a recognizable slot on the agenda.
But how do you sell the person who can walk into a room, understand its purpose, draw out different perspectives, create productive tension, involve hundreds of people, adapt in real time, and help the room arrive somewhere it could not have reached on its own? We haven’t built the same vocabulary, infrastructure, or perceived value around that work.
Yet Adler makes a provocative recommendation to organizers: Pick the format before the speaker, and vet the moderator/ facilitator like the keynote.
Amen!
What I take from Adler’s report isn’t that panel discussions are inherently weak. It’s that we need to stop defaulting to them without designing them.
A panel is not inherently a weak format. It is an unforgiving format.
Think about it. A keynote speaker can rehearse the presentation dozens, even hundreds, of times. The stories have been tested. The slides have been polished. The transitions have been practiced. The speaker knows which line will get a laugh, when the audience will lean in, and how the presentation will end.
A panel discussion is different. It is live. It is relational. And, if it is any good, it is somewhat unpredictable.
There’s no way to know exactly what a panelist is going to say.
Another panelist may agree, disagree, or take the conversation in a completely unexpected direction.
From the audience, an unexpected question could emerge—or one comment might create a murmur across the entire room.
And that is precisely where a panel can become compelling. I call this “working without a net.” It’s full of perils and pitfalls. It is also where weak facilitation becomes painfully obvious. There is nowhere to hide.
A skilled moderator/facilitator has to:
In other words, the moderator isn’t simply managing a panel. The moderator is facilitating an experience. Perhaps that is why Adler’s recommendation to “vet the facilitator like the keynote” resonated so strongly with me.
Selecting the right keynote speaker takes an enormous amount of effort.
Their videos are watched, their content carefully evaluated, and their references checked.
Fees are negotiated, expectations are discussed, and their ability to connect with the audience becomes a key consideration.
Then, too often, we put four people on stools and ask someone who is “good with people” or knowledgeable about the topic to moderate the panel. And then we wonder why it falls flat!
If we want a panel to deliver spectacle, learning, connection, and perhaps even some marketing value, we have to be just as intentional about the person facilitating the experience as we are about the people sitting on the panel.
So yes, David Adler, I agree with you. Please stop defaulting to the panel with a moderator and twenty minutes of Q&A. But don’t give up on the panel discussion.
Instead, start with a much better question: “What do we want this room to experience?”
Once we know what we want people to experience, then we can intentionally choose and design the format that will deliver it. And who knows? A powerful panel discussion just might be the ticket!
The 15 Genres of Panel Discussions
Media & Journalism Panels: Why Curiosity Beats Preparation
Business & Industry Panels: Why Relevance Beats Everything Else
Skip to content 