

The more I study, moderate, and dissect powerful panels, the more convinced I am of one thing: Most panel questions are accidentally designed to shut down conversation rather than spark it.
Here’s what usually happens:
The moderator curates a list of questions, assigns each one to a specific panelist, and we go down the line. The chosen panelist answers. Another panelist may jump in (if we’re lucky). Then we move on to the next question.
Nothing “wrong” with that format…But let’s be honest — there’s really no discussion.
This is one of the biggest traps moderators fall into. Too many “moderators” essentially conduct a series of mini interviews instead of facilitating an actual conversation. Panels become predictable, polite, and painfully linear.
But when I frame questions to create interplay, everything changes.
Here’s a real example where question framing changed everything:
Recently, I moderated a panel where one of the panelists’ big talking points was the importance of cultivating one-on-one relationships.
A typical moderator question might have been: “How do you cultivate one-on-one customer relationships so they stay with you for years?”
And yes — that would have gotten an answer.
A good answer.
A useful answer.
But it wouldn’t have sparked a conversation.
Instead, I posed a playful but revealing “Would you rather?” question:
“Would you rather spend time posting on social media… or touching base with your customers one-on-one?”
Instant energy shift.
Panelists laughed, reacted, debated, and jumped in without being asked. I also had the audience wave colored flags to vote (so much fun!), and that simple moment created contrast, disagreement, curiosity, and a cascade of personal stories.
Exactly what a panel should be.
And the best part?
This isn’t a gimmick. It’s rooted in real panel research.
Across all three of my books, two decades of panel reports, hundreds of panels, and dozens of expert moderator interviews, the message is clear:
My “Would you rather…” question hit all four.
So what’s the real lesson here? Most moderators think their job is to come up with smart questions. But the real magic comes from structuring questions that set up:
Questions that make panelists want to react to each other…not just respond to you. That’s when the energy shifts from “I’ll answer that” to
“Wait — I disagree with that!”
“Here’s what I’ve seen…”
“Let me build on that…”
When the panel starts talking to each other instead of taking turns talking to you, that’s when you know you’ve unlocked a powerful panel.
Start Your Panel Strong: 19 Creative Ways to Welcome with Impact
How to Push Panelists Beyond Platitudes and Into Practicality
Pardon the Interruption: A Fast-Paced Panel Format to Energize Your Discussion
For more information about how to moderate a lively & informative panel discussion, check out our free 7-part video series on how to moderate a panel and other resources to help you organize, moderate, or be a panel member.
Skip to content 